Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Who's who in the medical training world

In my last post, I alluded to different levels of medical training.  As I thought about the post later, I remembered that many of the patients I've interacted with over the years are confused about what those terms mean, and perhaps some of my lay readers are, too.

So, today I present the Singing Pen's guide to medical seniority:

Medical student = has completed a bachelor's (college) degree and is in a 4 year medical school program.  Medical students cannot independently provide any patient care; their patient notes and orders must be co-signed by a licensed physician (can be a resident or an attending).

Resident = has graduated from medical school and is training in his or her medical specialty of choice.  Residents must have medical licenses to practice and train, and a resident is rightfully referred to as "Doctor."  Graduating from medical school does not confer enough knowledge to practice independently in this day and age, though.*  Specialty training programs thus follow medical school for virtually all US med school grads; those programs are called "residencies" because, in the old days, residents actually lived (resided) in the hospital.

Intern = a first year resident.  This term is falling out of favor in some circles, as some residents and their teachers worry that it has developed a demeaning connotation.  The label persists partially because it's convenient (interns require the most supervision of all residents, given that they're fresh out of medical school) and partially because some medical specialties require a generic ("transitional") intern year program before joining their residency program (ophthalmology and physical med & rehab are two examples).

Fellow = a post-residency trainee.  Most residents go directly into independent practice after completing their residency, but some medical career paths require yet more training.  Many of the internal medicine specialities require fellowships: cardiology, endocrinology, nephrology, rheumatology, as do some of the surgical subspecialties.  Some fellowships focus less on patient care and more on academic training; I did a two-year faculty development fellowship following my family medicine residency to build my teaching and research skills.

Attending = done with training (but certainly never done with learning)!  Attendings bear the final responsibility for the trainees working with them.  Many attendings don't teach at all and just work independently, but those of us in academia work with students, residents, and fellows on a regular basis.

So, from the last educational level to the earliest:
Attending
Fellow
Resident
(Intern)
Medical student

Each level has responsibility to the levels below.  So, residents supervise medical students and attendings supervise residents' supervision of the medical students. As residency takes 3-6 years, depending on the specialty, higher-year (or "senior") residents often supervise newer residents ("junior" residents and/or interns, depending how each residency program labels its residents).

Some residency programs designate one, some, or all of their final-year residents as "chief residents" with varying levels of responsibility - from scheduling to teaching to representation - for their resident peers.  In many programs, being a chief resident is an elected honor.

Each year of medical school and then residency confers more responsibility and autonomy, ideally with the attending safety net always easily accessible.  Good attendings unobtrusively know everything that's going on with both the patients and their learners.  They gently guide the plan of care in the right direction, liberally sprinkle in teaching points, and avoid micro-managing every little detail.

I don't want to suggest, however, that the learning only moves in one direction. The constant challenge of keeping up with the latest evidence and studies is an energizing part of the job for many of us.  I learn more from the ideas and perspectives of the residents and students I am privileged to work with than I could ever teach them back.  This two-way learning makes academic medicine a very interesting place to be.

I consider myself one fortunate doc to get to teach every day, that's for sure.

* "General practice" as it used to be known in the US is no more.  Many family docs and internal med docs are frankly offended when people refer to them as a "general practitioner" or "g.p.," as these terms imply that their medical training ended after medical school (which used to be the case decades ago).  The vast majority of primary care docs in the US are board-certified "specialists" who have completed residencies in either family medicine, internal medicine, or pediatrics.

Monday, January 23, 2012

Patient comments about my age


I have gotten some interesting comments from patients regarding my age.

When I was a medical student, patients thought I was in high school.  When I was a resident, patients thought I was a college student.  Now, as an attending over five years out of residency, I get comments like "you sure know a lot for someone so young," well-intended compliments meant toward the resident I apparently appear to be.

An enviable problem to have, right?  Except I would like my patients' initial impression of me to be "professional and competent," not "nice and young."  I fear that patients will not trust me to manage their care if they think I'm so inexperienced.  I want them to have confidence in the recommendations I give them and the decisions we make together.  I have to admit, too, that a part of me wants my current station on the top of the medical training ladder to be acknowledged.

I wish it wasn't so, but it's true: I need my patients' affirmation as much as they may be looking for mine.  I'm ashamed of that confession; patients' duties should not include validating my insecurities.  I suspect, though, that I am not alone in constantly worrying about whether I am doing my best for my patients.

It's not so easy to evaluate your performance as a doctor, either.  No one is directly evaluating us, and the popular markers of success - productivity, income, government ratings - don't reflect the bulk of what our care with patients truly involves.   Patient satisfaction scores only go so far, since disgruntled patients can result when we correctly turn down unreasonable requests.  Quality improvement measures are a step in the right direction (1) but still don't answer the basic question: "did I follow the best path for this patient?"

It's all too easy to fall back on those numbers and patient affirmations to judge myself.  They each have their place in the overall picture of my practice, but I've got to center my focus on patient care where it belongs.

Just like the responsible 36-year-old I am.

(1) http://www.who.int/patientsafety/education/curriculum/who_mc_topic-7.pdf